Why More Visibility Isn't Always the Answer

Why more visibility isn't always the answer when customers aren't buying.

When sales slow down or bookings aren't where a business wants them to be, marketing often becomes the first place people look for a solution. Maybe the brand needs to post more consistently. Perhaps it's time to invest in advertising, work with influencers or launch a campaign to reach new customers.

Those might be reasonable ideas. But they assume the problem is that not enough people know the business exists.

And that's not always what's happening.

A business can have a recognizable brand, an active social media presence and steady website traffic without seeing the commercial results it expects. People may be discovering the business but not finding a compelling reason to choose it. They may be interested in the offering but uncertain about the value. Or they may be ready to purchase and encounter an experience that makes the decision unnecessarily difficult.

Before deciding that a business needs more attention, I'd want to understand what's happening with the attention it already receives.

Being seen isn't the same as being chosen

Consider a boutique hotel that's struggling to fill rooms during the week.

The owner might suggest a weekday promotion to encourage more reservations. Another recommendation might be to increase advertising so more travellers discover the property.

Neither approach is necessarily wrong.

But what if the hotel already attracts a reasonable number of visitors to its website? What if people are looking at the rooms but aren't completing reservations? Or what if the hotel is primarily communicating the same weekend getaway experience to people whose midweek travel needs are entirely different?

Those are three different situations.

A business traveller may care about location, reliable amenities and convenience. Someone planning a midweek getaway may need a compelling experience that justifies taking time away from their usual routine. A guest attending a local event may simply want accommodation that's close to the venue and easy to reserve.

The hotel could be visible to all three groups without giving each one enough reason to book.

In that situation, attracting more visitors to the same experience may do very little to change the outcome.

The customer may be interested, but something isn't connecting

This is where I'd start looking more closely at the customer journey.

What brings people to the business in the first place? What information do they encounter? What questions are they trying to answer? And what happens between their initial interest and the point where they're expected to make a decision?

For an ecommerce brand, the issue might be unclear product information, unexpected shipping costs or uncertainty about how a product fits into someone's routine.

For a restaurant, it could be that people enjoy the social content but can't easily find the menu, understand the experience or make a reservation.

For a service business, prospective customers might understand what's being offered without understanding whether it's appropriate for their particular situation.

None of these examples automatically calls for a bigger advertising budget.

They call for a closer look at what customers need to feel comfortable moving forward.

Of course, not every abandoned purchase or unanswered inquiry represents a marketing failure. People compare options, change their minds and sometimes have no immediate intention of buying.

The question is whether there are recurring patterns that the business can identify and meaningfully address.

More marketing can make an existing problem more expensive

There's a commercial consequence to investing in visibility before understanding what happens after discovery.

If a business is spending money to attract prospective customers who consistently leave without purchasing, increasing that spending could mean paying to send more people through the same unresolved experience.

That doesn't mean the business should stop advertising. It means the investment deserves closer examination.

I'd want to look at the relationship between traffic, inquiries, conversion and the value of the customers being acquired. I'd also consider whether expectations established through marketing match what the business actually delivers.

Sometimes the opportunity is to improve the website. Sometimes it's clarifying the offer, changing how the business communicates its value or reaching customers at a more relevant moment.

And sometimes awareness genuinely is the problem.

The important thing is understanding which situation you're dealing with before committing resources to a solution.

Start with the decision you're trying to influence

Marketing activity is relatively easy to recommend. There are always more channels to explore, campaigns to launch and content ideas to develop.

What's harder is identifying the decision a business needs its customers to make and understanding what's preventing that decision.

That requires looking beyond reach and engagement. It means paying attention to customer behaviour, business operations, the buying experience and the commercial results that follow.

For the boutique hotel, a weekday discount might ultimately make sense. But it could also turn out that a more relevant package, a local partnership or a clearer booking experience would be more effective.

You wouldn't know without investigating.

And that's why I think businesses need to be careful about treating every disappointing result as a visibility problem.

Before asking how to reach more people, it's worth understanding why the people you're already reaching aren't choosing you.


Could your marketing benefit from another perspective?

If you're questioning whether your current marketing is addressing the right problem, Harlowe can help you work through the options and identify where to focus next.

Previous
Previous

Before a New Product Hits the Shelf

Next
Next

What Building Harlowe Is Teaching Me About the Business Behind Marketing